I recently upgraded from Windows Home Server (WHS) to Windows Home Server 2011 (WHS2011). My old WHS machine was dying, and I was attracted to idea that WHS2011 was a 64 bit OS, and would hopefully perform better. I installed WHS2011 onto a 64 bit VMWare virtual machine with 4GB ram, a 200GB virtual for the OS, 3TB storage on an external USB HDD and a 100 GB virtual disk to backup the OS.
Incidentally, the OS only formatted up a 2GB partition on the 3GB drive, leaving a separate 1TB partition unused. I formatted this up later and added it to the pool.
I encountered several problems, but have overcome them all, and am very happy with the result.
1. WHS provided Drive Extender Technology, but WHS2011 does not.
A cool feature about the original WHS was that you could add extra storage to the box on the fly, and WHS would allocate it to one large storage pool. So rather than having a bunch of disparate disks of all different sizes, they’d all appear as one huge drive.
This feature was dropped from WHS2011.
That meant if one of my drives filled up, and I wanted to add more storage, it would appear in the system as a separate drive, and I’d have to alter my backup plans to use the new drive.
I got around this problem by installing DriveBender – a WHS2011 add-in which allows me to dynamically manage the size of my storage pools, provides redundancy, and makes managing a bunch of drives a lot easier. It only cost me $40, which (even for a tight-wad like me) was money well spent.
2. Disk Errors caused backups to fail
After a while, the USB drive started to fail. WHS 2011 reported that the Windows Server Client Computer Backup Service was not running. I tried to start it manually, but it failed. The event log gave the following error:
“ReadHeader File: D:\ServerFolders\Client Computer Backups\Commit.dat Error: Unable to complete the requested operation because of either a catastrophic media failure or a data structure corruption on the disk.”
To get around this problem, I used DriveBender to add a second (2TB) USB drive to the pool. I then used DriveBender to remove the faulty (3TB) UDB drive from the pool. Removing the faulty drive took about 36 hours. Basically DriveBender had to check the CRC of every file on the drive before copying it.
After removing the faulty drive, I stil received the same error, so I did a “repair” on the backup database, which fixed the problem.
I was then able to reformat and add the original drive back into the pool.
At the same time, I enabled data redundancy on the pool, so that every file added after that was duplicated on a second drive.
3. I could not connect to WHS2011 with Launchpad from one machine
This was the most annoying error of all and took me days to fix.
I had an old XP machine that refused to connect.
Whenever I tried to sign in I’d get the following error:
The server appears to be offline. Do you want to sign in to offline mode?
This happened, even though I could use Dashboard, and was able to access shares on the server from the old XP machine.
I scoured the web for solutions. Here’s a few I tried to no avail.
1. Uninstall and reinstall the WHS2011. As well as uninstalling the connector, I deleted all records of the old XP machine from the WHS2011 catalog. After reinstalling WHS2011 on the old XP machine Launchpad still would not connect to the server.
2. Uninstall and reinstall the .NET 4.0 framework. I restarted the machine after uninstalling, and even combined the process with uninstalling / reinstalling WHS2011. No joy. I still could not connect.
3. Disable my local firewall. Disable all inter-computer communication restrictions on my Endian firewall. Basically I was trying to make sure nothing was blocking communications between the old XP machine and the server. No success. I still could not connect.
4. Increase the ServicesPipeTimeout setting in the registry. The idea behind this was that perhaps it was taking a while for Launchpad to connect with the server. If I increased the timeout, perhaps it might have a better chance of successfully connecting. No joy. I still could not connect.
In desperation, I used the Wireshark packet tracer, as well as my Endian Firewalls log files to trace any packets from the old XP machine to the server. To my great surprise not a single packet was being transmitted. There were not even any unsuccessful transmissions. The workstation didn’t even appear to be trying to communicate. This led me to think that perhaps there was something wrong with the Winsock component on the client workstation. I.e. something on the local machine was stopping the communication before it even left the local machine.
So I tried listing all the LSP’s installed on the local machine using this command:
netsh winsock show catalog
This showed up something really interesting. I noticed that there was an old antivirus system (Comodo Antivirus) installed on the workstation. It wasn’t being used, but it had installed an LSP which was blocking communication between the old XP machine and the server.
I uninstalled Comodo Antivirus from the workstation, rebooted, and BINGO, Launchpad was able to connect.
I now have a fully functional WHS2011 backup solution. It has redundancy, scalable storage, and works like a charm. A couple of weeks ago, one of the local machines failed. I just rebooted that machine from a WHS2011 recovery CD, and it was up and running again in about 90 minutes.
If you’re having problems with WHS2011, I hope this post helps you sort them out.
